Here’s a reality check for rugby fans: the future of several Exeter Chiefs stars hangs in the balance, and it’s not just about their performance on the field. But here’s where it gets controversial—Rob Baxter, the Chiefs' director of rugby, has bluntly revealed that he hasn’t even begun contract negotiations with players whose deals expire at the end of the season. Why? Because he’s waiting to see if they’re truly worth keeping. This isn’t just about skill; it’s about fit, form, and the team’s long-term vision. And this is the part most people miss—Baxter isn’t just evaluating individual talent; he’s rebuilding a squad capable of sustained success.
Among the players in limbo are England star Henry Slade, who’s expressed a desire to stay despite external ties to R360, and Josh Hodge, linked with a return to Newcastle Red Bulls. The Roots brothers, Ethan and Jimmy, along with Will Goodrick-Clarke, Ehren Painter, Dan John, and Olly Woodburn, are also in their final contract years. Baxter’s message is clear: prove your worth, or risk moving on.
In a candid interview, Baxter explained, ‘We didn’t have a great season last year, so I’m not rushing to re-sign everyone. I want to see how the team evolves, how players perform, and whether our squad composition is right.’ This approach, while pragmatic, is sure to spark debate. Is it fair to keep players in limbo? Or is it a necessary strategy in professional sports?
Baxter isn’t just focusing on contracts; he’s also optimistic about the team’s current form. With nine points from their first three games and new Wallabies stars Len Ikitau and Tom Hooper set to face Harlequins, the Chiefs are off to a stronger start than last season. ‘We’re building a foundation,’ Baxter said. ‘We’re competitive in many areas, and the players look brighter.’
But let’s circle back to the contract situation—it’s a bold move that could either unite or divide fans. Here’s the controversial question: Is Baxter’s approach a smart way to rebuild a winning team, or is he risking morale and loyalty by keeping players in uncertainty? Let’s hear your thoughts in the comments. One thing’s for sure: the coming months will be pivotal for both the Chiefs and their players, as every game becomes a trial for their future.
